To This Day a Shepherd


Author: José Maria J. Yulo

Our final cause is not tied to this world we live in. Though we inhabit the world for a rather temporary span of time, we do have enough time, no matter what polity or era we live in, to decide for ourselves whether or not we will accept the purpose for which we are created…

Catholicism and Intelligence by James V. Schall, S.J. (Emmaus Road Publishing, 2017)

catholicism intelligenceLook upwards, then! Contemplate this place which is a habitation for all eternity! Then you will not need any longer to be at the mercy of what the multitude says about you: Then you will not have to put your trust in whatever human rewards your achievements may earn.[1]

In other words, Plato turned his face to truth, but his back on Mr. H.G. Wells, when he turned to his museum of specified ideals.[2]

It may be stated with more than some measure of assurance that Fr. James V. Schall, S.J., former Professor of Government at Georgetown University, possesses qualities which may be considered Chestertonian. Not only does he possess Gilbert Keith Chesterton’s fidelity to the Roman Catholic Church, but, in so doing, he additionally exhibits the latter’s ability to redistill seemingly complex and ethereal concepts into the vessel where they were meant to reside, in humanity’s shared common sense. This is precisely what Fr. Schall does in his latest book, Catholicism and Intelligence.[3]

Echoing Chesterton’s own unique penchant for humor and seeing the profundity in simple things, Fr. Schall early on references a Peanuts cartoon wherein Lucy is visiting Charlie Brown at home. She informs him that not only does her house have a larger TV, but her house is also better owing to her father making more money than Charlie’s. To all of these, Charlie Brown is constant in his good-naturedness. Ultimately, he hopes Lucy enjoys her house and TV, and he is happy for her to do so. This, of course, infuriates Lucy, who lets Charlie know that he drives her crazy. Well, at least she has that TV to turn to.

Fr. Schall writes that Catholicism’s claim to the truth is akin to Charlie’s good-naturedness, seemingly immune from the envy and resentment others try to induce by touting matters of earthly prestige. And, to this, there is also a correlation of Lucy and critics of Catholicism. “This claim to truth, both of reason and revelation, does drive the modern world crazy. As implied in John’s Gospel, truth incites the persecution that Christ told His disciples to expect.”[4] He furthers this point, writing that even the most reasonable teachings of Catholicism, “sound crazy in a world that denies any order in nature or in the human being that is not placed there by man alone.”[5]

It is not altogether unique for Fr. Schall to cite Catholicism’s claim to truth in both reason and revelation. One of the sources he often quotes, Pope John Paul II, wrote that reason and faith were the two wings upon which human beings ascend to the truth. Yet, it is the specific and perceptive manner in how revelation and reason are oriented towards each other which Fr. Schall keenly stresses.

To this end, he first explains how of all places Paul the Apostle could have been sent to preach and promulgate the new faith, it was not the more populated far corners of the world, but Greece which was chosen. Unlike most civilizations of the time and before, the Greeks were not brimming with diverse religious activity. Rather, theirs was a land of thinkers purporting to love wisdom, a land of philosophers. Here, there was great import, as, “Christianity had to relate itself first to philosophy, not to other religions, precisely in order that it could be seen as universal.”[6] Had this not been achieved, there would have been no shared basis from which to have dealings with other differing faiths or philosophies. Likewise, Christianity, “would have had no common ground from within human reason whereby it could evaluate the truth of its own revelation as well as that of other religions.”[7]

Revelation’s role in this was seemingly less broad than it would seem. It was not meant to supplant reason, nor instruct it in what we could know or understand by it. This, Fr. Schall posits, comes from the authority of the Gospels themselves. “The Gospel also wants us to use our heads for our own sake. We are, if we can, to figure out what we need to do by ourselves.”[8] Revelation, as it was, was fashioned in such a way to address itself directly to human reason. Via the agency of reason, revelation is addressed to man in his wholeness. It was not meant to contradict reason or be irrational. In a manner, revelation was a gift, or boon to reason. “In seeking to understand the meaning of revelation, reason in fact became more, not less, reasonable.”[9] In addition, revelation was specifically addressed to reason when the latter was at its best, when it was most reasonable, “most consciously thinking of the reality of what is.”[10]

When what is becomes the subject of human contemplation via reason, which itself has revelation addressed to it, the outcome according to Fr. Schall is the realization of humanity’s place in it. Our final cause, as Aristotle would have put it, is not tied to this world we live in. Though we inhabit the world for a rather temporary span of time, we do have enough time, “no matter what polity or era we live in, to decide for ourselves whether or not we will accept the purpose for which we are created.”[11] This, Fr. Schall says, is the main message of importance revelation bequeathed to human beings.

The position through which human beings decide to either accept or refuse their purposes, or final causes, establishes that such creatures are secondary causes. These, as Fr. Schall states, are beings, “capable of their own activities or at least of having separate existence.”[12] Those of the modern scientific, or even scientistic point of view which eschews all but evidence-based reason, require a world populated by such secondary causes in order to go beyond thinking about the world, and onto actually investigating it. The existence of secondary causes is given more meaning by the addition of, “the idea that things are good and had a beginning,”[13] which was itself a conclusion of revelation, both Christian and Jewish. Uniquely, Fr. Schall points out, science did not grow from soil without these ideas from reason addressed by revelation.

It would seem odd then that the specific Western culture (in modern guise) from which science was able to spawn from, itself produces philosophies which seek to sever the ties between reason and revelation, and perhaps from reason and the human mind as well. The culprit here would not be the intellect itself, which is ordered to reason, but rather the will, which has plans of its own. “For much modern thought wants to cut our minds off from what is. Many see this cutting off of any relation of mind to reality as a way to liberate us so that we can do whatever we want.”[14]

There is poignant irony in this elevation of the arbitrariness of the will as a measure of freedom. This voluntarism wills to liberate via the elimination of personal accountability for one’s decisions. The will desires to not have to exercise itself for any decision which has true bearing on the whole of which it only constitutes a part. Yet, it itself cannot do this without first casting a vote in rejection of the ultimate purpose the entire being which it inhabits was meant for. “Truth means to conform our minds to what is, not the other way around.”[15] For the modern mind of the West, freedom would appear to come via the route of rejecting what it means to be free.

This voluntarism which stands athwart the truth espoused by the Catholic mind finds a strange cohort in the thought that drives the atrocities perpetrated by those seeking to establish a medieval Caliphate anew in the modern world. Fr. Schall writes that the Islamic State has no reservations about dubbing itself the true standard of its faith. It scorns Muslims who diverge from their vision, planning to silence these in time. With its aim being the conquest of the world, this also means everyone being brought under Islamic law which is taken as the will of Allah. Using force instead of reason and argument to attain this end is valid in the Caliphate’s holy book and its, “philosophic voluntarism that explains how Allah can at one-time talk of peace and then talk of war without any problem or need to resolve the contradiction.”[16]

Whereas in the aforementioned modern schools of philosophy which subordinate reason to the will in order to presumably be free from what is, Fr. Schall claims reason is at best a tool, or means to an end to those of this vision of a renewed Caliphate. “The world itself and all events in it are directly caused by Allah’s will.”[17] What links these brands of thought according to Fr. Schall, ultimately, is the negation of the existence of human beings as secondary causes, ironically something which the Catholic mind reasons, with revelation addressed to it, human beings were meant to be.

Toward the end of the book, Fr. Schall draws on Chesterton himself to approximate man’s lot, possessed as he is with revelation directed to his reason. Chesterton wrote that no other animal is afflicted with the phenomenon of laughter, perhaps a sign that man catches glimpses of deeper mysteries weaved into the fabric of the universe which it is itself unaware of. It is as if though he is living on earth, his home, he is nonetheless homesick.

As it turns out, this is due to each individual person having within immense value, something not simply discerned by vaunted human reason. “Man, each man, is more important than the cosmos. This fact is our dignity, in spite of the many theories that argue or imply that we have no dignity because the universe has no inner or external reason.”[18] Chesterton claimed for it to be unnatural to see man as simply a product of nature. In this latest work by Fr. Schall, one finds out the cause for this, a conclusion reached by Catholicism and intelligence. “That is, there rings in each man’s being an end higher than that due to his nature as simply a rational animal.”[19] Perhaps this, in the end, is why Catholicism and intelligence render someone akin to Charlie Brown who was eternally good-natured and content with his own house, TV, and father.

Books on the topic of this essay may be found in The Imaginative Conservative BookstoreThe Imaginative Conservative applies the principle of appreciation to the discussion of culture and politics—we approach dialogue with magnanimity rather than with mere civility. Will you help us remain a refreshing oasis in the increasingly contentious arena of modern discourse? Please consider donating now.


[1] Cicero, On the Good Life, (London: Penguin Classics, 1971), 352.

[2] G. K. Chesterton, Heretics, (New York: Barnes and Noble, 2007), 41.

[3] James V. Schall, S.J., Catholicism and Intelligence, (Steubenville: Emmaus Road Publishing, 2017).

[4] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 51.

[5] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 51.

[6] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 84.

[7] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 84.

[8] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 85.

[9] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 85.

[10] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 85.

[11] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 43.

[12] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 89.

[13] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 89

[14] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 87.

[15] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 87.

[16] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 106.

[17] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 106.

[18] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 124.

[19] Schall, Catholicism and Intelligence, 124-125.

The post To This Day a Shepherd appeared first on The Imaginative Conservative.

To Visit Source of Story Click >>> The Imaginative Conservative


  1. I’m not sure where you’re getting your information, but good topic. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more. Thanks for wonderful info I was looking for this info for my mission.

  2. Hi there I am so happy I found your blog page, I really found you by accident, while I was browsing on Aol for something else, Anyhow I am here now and would just like to say kudos for a fantastic post and a all round interesting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to browse it all at the moment but I have book-marked it and also added your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read more, Please do keep up the fantastic job.

  3. Hello, Neat post. There is an issue with your web site in internet explorer, would test this… IE still is the market leader and a good portion of other people will omit your fantastic writing due to this problem.

  4. I precisely wanted to say thanks all over again. I’m not certain what I might have sorted out without the type of tactics documented by you over this area. It seemed to be the scary case in my opinion, however , spending time with your well-written fashion you treated that took me to leap over gladness. I’m just happier for the service and in addition sincerely hope you find out what a great job you happen to be putting in teaching the mediocre ones by way of your site. I’m certain you’ve never encountered any of us.

  5. We’re a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community. Your site provided us with valuable info to work on. You have done a formidable job and our entire community will be grateful to you.

  6. Today, while I was at work, my cousin stole my apple ipad and tested to see if it can survive a forty foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad is now destroyed and she has 83 views. I know this is completely off topic but I had to share it with someone!

  7. I totally adore your blog and find many of your posts to be precisely what I’m looking for. Would you offer people to write information for you? I would not mind producing a story relating to garageband online or perhaps on a lot of the topics you’re writing about on this page. Again, awesome internet site!

  8. I personally arrived right here from another web address about showbox download and imagined I should look at this. I really like what I see therefore now I”m following you. Looking forward to finding out about your site yet again.

  9. I’m truly loving the design of your website. Do you ever come across any kind of browser compatibility troubles? A few of the website audience have lamented regarding my download showbox website not working effectively in Explorer though seems very good in Chrome. Have you got any kind of recommendations to assist repair this matter?

  10. Appreciating the persistence you invested in your blog and thorough material you present. It really is amazing to come across a blog once in a while which is not the similar expired rehashed information. Excellent read! We’ve bookmarked your blog and I am including the RSS feeds to my facetime for android download website.

  11. Nice read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing some research on that. And he just bought me lunch because I found it for him smile Thus let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch!

  12. Hello! I’m at work browsing your blog from my new apple iphone! Just wanted to say I love reading through your blog and look forward to all your posts! Keep up the outstanding work!

  13. It was actually great to read this and I think you are 100 right. Inform me in the event that you are thinking about garageband download windows, that’s my primary competency. I hope to check back with you in the near future, take care!

  14. I really like the things you guys are up to. Such clever effort and visibility! Keep up the fantastic work guys, I have incorporated you to my personal garageband windows free site.

  15. I personally came right here from a different web address related to lucky patcher apk download and considered I might read this. I adore the things I see so now I am following you. Getting excited about checking out the blog yet again.

  16. Thanks for discussing this, I bookmarked this page. I’m furthermore searching for information around mobdro for android, are you aware the place where I could find something like that? I’ll return in the future!

  17. Admiring the commitment you put into the blog and comprehensive information you present. It’s good to discover a website every now and then which is just not the same old rehashed material. Excellent read! We’ve bookmarked your site and I am including your RSS feeds to my own framaroot apk site.

  18. I really like the things you are now up to. This sort of cool work and exposure! Keep up the amazing effort guys, I have included you on my own vshare iphone download web page.